After-Hours and Premarket Trading: Managing the Stock Trading Jitters

After-Hours and Premarket Trading: Managing the Stock Trading Jitters

Key Takeaways

    Many markets are open for trading between the close and the next day’s opening bell

    At-the-money options reach their height of uncertainty just before expiration

    Stubbornness and other mental mistakes can sometimes lead to stress during premarket trading

If you’re like most people, you have a bedtime routine—lock the doors, brush your teeth, find your spiritual center, etc. If you carry outstanding positions, do you tuck them in at night?

Even though you may be sleeping, the market isn’t. Somewhere in the world, data is being released, news is being made, and markets are responding. Even in your hometown when it’s dark, some people are probably participating in after-hours or premarket trading. And if you have positions on—especially those that may have weighed on your mind during the trading day—it’s often during the overnight and premarket hours when those thoughts and feelings might be most acutely felt.

So, grab that milk and plate of cookies and let’s look at some things that keep traders up at night—and what you can do about them.

Premarket Trading: Log In, Monitor, Tap, or Click

After-Hours and Premarket Trading: Managing the Stock Trading Jitters

First things first. If you find yourself thinking about premarket stock trading or after-hours trading at night, think about trading at night. Many of your favorite markets are open and available in the overnight hours—and virtually around the clock.

Premarket and after-hours trading. TD Ameritrade offers premarket trading (from 7–9:28 a.m. ET) and again in so-called after-hours trading (from 4:02–8:00 p.m. ET). Companies typically report earnings either before the opening bell or right after the close, so these periods can help you navigate positions outside of normal hours. But be careful: Stocks are typically less liquid and more volatile in premarket and after-hours trading, especially right before or after a news release.

24/5 trading. TD Ameritrade was the first U.S. retail broker to offer overnight trading in select securities, available 24/5 via the thinkorswim® platform and the thinkorswim mobile app. As of September 2021, the list of available securities included a broad selection of exchange-traded funds (ETFs) covering a wide range of sectors. Check the complete list of 24/5 securities, or go to the Trade tab on thinkorswim and look for the purple EXTO Eligible sign, which stands for extended hours overnight (see figure 1).

After-Hours and Premarket Trading: Managing the Stock Trading Jitters

FIGURE 1: COME IN; WE’RE OPEN. TD Ameritrade allows trading of certain securities 24/5 on the thinkorswim platform or thinkorswim mobile app. For illustrative purposes only.

Futures. Approved accounts can access the futures market 23.5 hours a day, six days a week. (Futures open at 5 p.m. CT on Sunday and close for the week at 4 p.m. CT Friday.) These derivative contracts allow you to hedge or speculate on stock indices such as the S&P 500 (/ES) and Nasdaq-100 (/NQ); commodities like crude oil, gold, and agricultural products; and interest rates, foreign currencies, and more. Note that futures involve substantial risk, are not suitable for all investors and require margin, which can magnify losses as well as gains. Learn more about futures to see if they’re in your future.    

Now you can trade all night long.

Research. Even if you’re not interested in premarket stock trading, after hours can still be the best time to prepare trading strategies. Many traders use this time to evaluate previous trades (the losers as well as the winners), check the charts, research the fundamentals, and develop their game plan. Want to experiment with something new? The off hours might be the time to log in to your paperMoney® account and place simulated trades for deeper analysis.

Remember, if you do end up spending time on the trading platform at night or engage in after-hours trading, you still need to get adequate rest. Burning the candle at both ends isn’t likely to be sustainable in the long term.

Options Expiration: When the Cradle Rocks

As option traders know, the closer you get to expiration, the more uncertain the outcome of your positions—particularly those that are at the money. At expiration, an option contract’s delta is either zero (out of the money and expires worthless) or 1.00 (in the money and exercised or assigned). That delta uncertainty—which intensifies the closer you get to expiration—is called gamma.

Furthermore, although each option decays throughout its life (called theta), that decay becomes more pronounced the closer you get to expiration. If you’re long options, you want the market to move (and in the right direction). If you’re short, you’d like the market to stay still so you can get the most out of your theta.

The common thread here is uncertainty. Is all that uncertainty weighing on your mind at 3 a.m.? If so, it might be time to reassess your strategy. Perhaps your position sizes are too big. Or maybe carrying options positions into expiration isn’t your cup of tea. If so, consider closing out or rolling options positions before they start playing with your mind. It’s important to note that equity options don’t trade in the after-hours sessions and rolling strategies can incur additional transaction costs.

Beta Weighting and Overnight Trading

Have you ever used beta weighting to assess your portfolio? When you have a lot of positions, you may want a straightforward way to assess them against a single benchmark. The beta weighting tool on thinkorswim lets you see how your positions—stocks, ETFs, futures, and options included—perform against a given index. The tool lets you assess the positions against movement in the benchmark, with the passage of time, and as volatility rises and falls.

What does beta weighting have to do with overnight trading? If you beta weight your portfolio to a comparable index, index ETF, or a sector ETF, you might be able to hedge or trade around your positions with index futures or EXTO securities.

Let’s Not Quarrel

Ever heard the phrase “don’t go to bed angry,” popular in premarital counseling? That applies to your trading positions as well. If you find yourself doing battle with something in your account—maybe a position that you’re hanging on to out of stubbornness or spite—you either need to accept it for what it is or be prepared to part ways.

There’s another phrase traders sometimes use: “Blowing through a mental stop order.” A mental stop is kind of like a regular stop order, but it’s not one you enter as a trade—it’s one that stays inside your head. And if you blew through it, that means you told yourself you’d close out a loser if it went against you by X amount. Then when it went against you by X amount, you hung on. Or worse, maybe you even doubled your position.

You know what they call traders who aren’t disciplined in their exit points? Ex-traders.

You don’t want to be an ex-trader. When a position is keeping you up at night, it could be a sign that you’re not being true to your trading strategy. It could be time to address a possible strategy change head-on.

No job should be an all-day/all-night gig, and that’s especially true with trading—whether you trade for a living or in your spare time. So, make sure you’re giving your trader brain what it needs so you can get that shut-eye when you need it. If that means dispensing with premarket stock trading or after-hours trading for a while, so be it.

But if you get the urge to log in during the wee hours, the platforms (and many of the products you trade) are open for business. Pass the cookies, please.

Doug Ashburn is not a representative of TD Ameritrade, Inc. The material, views, and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author and may not be reflective of those held by TD Ameritrade, Inc.

Leave a comment